Tetra In Action #8 - June, 2017

Grade 91 Piping Risk Assessment

Higher demands on outlet steam conditions has led to the increased use of modified low alloy materials (9-12% Cr), such as Grade 91. The superior high temperature material properties of these types of steels (strength, fatigue resistance, creep resistance, improved steam oxidation resistance) gives the designer advantages with respect to boiler reliability and thermal performance. There are many advantages of using this type of material; however, the long-term integrity has been an industry-wide concern ever since the first installations occurred. Tetra Engineering recently published an article in the Engineering Failure Analysis journal titled "Premature Grade 91 failures - worldwide plant operational experience" presenting our experience of premature Grade 91 failures from North America, Europe, the Middle East and Asia. If you are interested in a Grade 91 risk assessment, contact Peter Jackson (This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.) for North/Central and South America or Andreas Fabricius (This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.) for Europe/Middle East/Asia.  

Thermal Simulations using PPS&D

Power Plant Simulator & Designer (PPS&D) provides state-of-the-art capabilities for modeling and simulating the operation of nearly any type of thermal power plant. Originally developed by KED GmbH in Germany for use by boiler OEMs in their detailed design work, PPS&D has since been used by numerous clients worldwide for simulating the operation of many types of boilers and thermal power plants.

  • Natural & forced circulation boilers, both sub- and super-critical

  • Pulverized coal boilers

  • Combined cycle power plants, heat recovery steam generators including once-through and Benson designs

  • Municipal waste incinerators

  • Fire tube boilers

  • Fluidized-bed combustion boilers

 Model Steady-State and Dynamic Boiler Operation

PPS&D is available in a basic version for performing steady-state simulations of plant operation. The enhanced version adds dynamic simulation, allowing testing and integration of key steam cycle control functions, and evaluation of system tran­sient (startup, shutdown, process upset) response.

hrsg waterside triple pressure

Waterside scheme of triple pressure HRSG

More information about thermal simulations can be found here.


HRSG Inspection Planning Guide Snapshots

Tensile overload tube failures have become more common with the introduction of the larger combustion turbines that are typical of new combined cycle power plants.  These failures are predominantly in reheater and superheater tubes, where inadequate drain capability exists during startup/shutdown or where desuperheater spray valves are not functioning appropriately.  Desuperheater spray valve hardware and control logic have both contributed to these failures.   

Effective inspection techniques for this damage mechanism depend on the severity and can include:

  • Visual
  • Dye Penetrant
  • Magnetic Particle
  • Radiography

If you are interested in the full version of the HRSG Inspection Planning Guide (2nd edition) contact Ms Christine Vallon at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..